Governance Without Bureaucracy

The word “governance” makes most mid-sized companies wince. It sounds like committees, binders and approval chains that slow everyone down.

But without some governance, a program drifts. Rates creep up. Suppliers multiply. Managers work around the process. Within a year or two you are back where you started, now with a system on top. I’ve seen it happen- a program owner leaves the organization, the oversight is no longer a priority since no one is managing it, and hiring managers were allowed to skirt the program. 

Good governance at this size is small and simple. It exists to answer four questions: who decides, what are the rules, how do we know it is working, and what do we do when it is not.

1. Name an owner

The single most important governance step is naming one person accountable for the program. Not a committee, and not “procurement and HR together.” One person, with enough authority to enforce standards and enough time to do the job.

At $10-50 million in spend, this is often a part-time role for someone in procurement, HR operations or finance. If it is part-time, protect the time. Programs fail when the owner’s real job crowds out the program.

Behind the owner, set up a light steering group: the owner, a finance representative, an HR or talent leader, and an executive sponsor. Meet quarterly, not monthly, unless something is wrong.

2. Write a short policy

You do not need a 40-page manual. A two-to-three-page policy that covers the following is enough:

  • Who can engage contingent workers and for what purposes
  • Which suppliers to use and how to request an exception
  • Approved rate ranges for common roles
  • Required agreements and onboarding steps
  • Maximum tenure, and what happens when a worker reaches it
  • How invoices are approved

The test of a good policy is whether a hiring manager can read it in ten minutes and follow it.

3. Tier your suppliers

Most mid-sized programs have too many suppliers. A tiered approach brings order without needing an elaborate process.

TierWhoHow you manage them
PreferredA small group of suppliers with the most spend and best performanceStandard agreements, agreed rates, regular reviews
ApprovedSuppliers used for specific skills or locationsStandard agreements, reviewed annually
ExceptionOne-off or niche suppliersRequires owner approval, reviewed for consolidation

The goal is not to cut suppliers for its own sake. It is to concentrate volume where you get better rates and service, and to know why every supplier is on the list.

4. Build a one-page scorecard

A scorecard that tracks 30 metrics gets ignored. One that tracks eight to ten gets used. Choose a few in each of four areas:

  • Cost: total spend, spend by supplier, average rate versus approved range
  • Quality: time to fill, submission-to-hire ratio, manager satisfaction, early terminations
  • Compliance: workers without a current agreement, workers over tenure limits, exceptions granted
  • Supplier performance: invoice accuracy, on-time submissions, responsiveness

For each metric, define what it means, where the data comes from and who is responsible. Review the scorecard monthly at the owner level and quarterly with the steering group.

Invoice accuracy and timeliness are worth watching closely. When it slips, the impact it can have on your financials can become problematic.

5. Set a review rhythm

  • Monthly: the owner reviews the scorecard and follows up on exceptions
  • Quarterly: the steering group reviews results and decides on changes to suppliers or policy
  • Annually: a fuller review of the model, technology and supplier tiers

This takes a few hours a month. If it takes much more, the design is too heavy.

Keeping it lean

A few habits prevent governance from turning into bureaucracy:

  • Every rule should have a reason you can explain in one sentence.
  • Make the right way the easy way. If following the process is harder than going around it, people go around it.
  • Review exceptions. A growing pile of exceptions means the rule is wrong, or enforcement is weak.
  • Retire what is not used. A report nobody reads should be removed.

Next step

Governance only works if people follow it, and that depends on adoption. Article 6 covers how to get hiring managers on board and how to show results in the first year.

If you want help designing a policy, scorecard or supplier tiers that fit your company, I am glad to talk. Email me at becky@ennisbader.com to schedule a 20 minute discussion..

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *