Tag: #VMS

  • Choosing a VMS at Mid-Market Scale: What to Require, What to Skip

    A vendor management system (VMS) is the technology backbone of most contingent workforce programs. It handles requisitions, supplier submissions, approvals, onboarding, time and invoicing, and gives you the data to see what is happening.

    For a company at $10-50 million in spend, choosing one is a big decision, and the buying process is often tilted against you. Demos are built to impress. Feature lists run to hundreds of lines. Pricing is hard to compare.

    Here is how I would approach it.

    Start with requirements, not vendors

    If you did the baseline in Article 3, you already know your spend, suppliers, rates and process. Use that to write requirements before you see a single demo. Make sure that you understand what your current pain points are and what you are trying to solve with the technology and the program.

    Split them into three groups:

    • Must-haves: things that, if missing, make the system unusable for you
    • Should-haves: things that would save time or reduce risk
    • Nice-to-haves: things that look good in a demo but you would rarely use

    Most mid-sized programs need fewer must-haves than they think. Typical ones include requisition workflow, supplier management, approval routing, time and expense, invoicing, reporting, and integration with your finance or HR systems.

    What to require

    Fit for your worker types. If you use staff augmentation and project-based or statement of work labor, confirm the system handles both well. Some handle one far better than the other.

    By the numbers: project work is moving into the VMS

    Spend flowing through vendor management systems rose 7% to $303 billion in 2025, up from 4% growth in 2024, according to SIA’s VMS Global Landscape Summary. Statement-of-work spend made up 39% of the 2025 total, and SIA’s analyst notes that platforms are investing in SOW management and interoperability, so buyers see more value in bringing projects into the VMS. Single-country programs were 72% of VMS clients and 38% of spend, while the 9% of clients running global programs accounted for 36% of spend.

    Source: SIA, “VMS spend rises to $303B with increase in SOW,” Sept. 2, 2026.

    Coverage for where you operate. Check countries, currencies, languages and local compliance needs. If any of your workers or hiring managers work in another language, test the experience in that language, not just a checkbox that says it is supported.

    Reporting you can use. Ask to see standard reports with your kind of data and find out what it takes to build a custom one. Reporting is why most companies buy a VMS, so test it hard.

    Integration. Ask exactly how the system connects to your finance, HR and payroll systems, who builds and maintains the connection, and what it costs.

    Ease for hiring managers. If managers find the system hard to use, they will work around it, and your program loses visibility. Ask for hands-on time, not a scripted walkthrough.

    What to skip, or at least not pay for

    Enterprise features add cost and complexity. Be careful with:

    • Deep configurability you will not use in your first two years
    • Elaborate workflow engines for approval chains you do not have
    • Modules for worker types you do not engage
    • Advanced analytics and AI features that depend on data volume you do not have yet

    This is not a rule against growth features. It is a reminder to buy for the program you will run in the next two to three years, with a path to add more.

    Questions I would ask every vendor

    1. How many clients at my spend level do you serve, and may I speak with two?
    2. What does implementation look like for a company our size: timeline, your team, our team?
    3. Who supports us after go-live, and what happens when that person changes?
    4. What is included in the price, and what costs extra: integrations, reporting, additional users, additional countries, support?
    5. How does pricing change as our spend grows or shrinks?
    6. What happens to our data if we leave?
    7. What are the three most common reasons clients are unhappy, and how do you address them?

    Pay attention to how specific the answers are. Vague answers to question 2 or question 4 usually mean surprises later.

    Evaluating mid-market pricing

    VMS pricing varies: a fee based on spend, a per-worker fee, a flat license (or subscription), or a mix. Ask each vendor to price the same scenario, using your own numbers, so you can compare like with like. Include one-time implementation, ongoing fees and the cost of anything you need that is not in the base package.

    Implementation and adoption matter more than features

    In my experience, the system a company selects matters less than how it is implemented and adopted. A good system, poorly rolled out, delivers poor results. A solid system with a clear plan, trained managers and a committed owner delivers strong ones.

    When you compare vendors, weigh the quality of their implementation support at least as heavily as the feature list. Ask who will actually do the work, how many projects they run at once, and what happens when something goes wrong.

    A simple selection process

    1. Finalize requirements from your baseline.
    2. Shortlist three to four vendors that serve your size.
    3. Send a short written questionnaire rather than a long RFP.
    4. Hold scripted demos using your own scenarios.
    5. Check references, including a client who had a difficult implementation.
    6. Compare pricing on the same scenario.
    7. Decide with a small group that includes someone who will use the system daily.

    Next step

    A system without good governance is just an expensive database. Article 5 covers how to keep control of your program without building a bureaucracy.

    If you are comparing vendors and would like a second set of eyes on requirements or demos, I would be glad to help. Email me at becky@ennisbader.com to schedule a 20 minute discussion.

  • If You’re a Staffing Firm Inside Someone Else’s Managed Program, Here’s What Moves the Needle

    Working inside a client’s MSP or VMS is different from working a client directly. The relationship is no longer just you and the hiring manager. There is a program, a set of rules, a scorecard, and often a provider sitting between you and the buyer.

    I have spent decades on the supplier side of these programs as well as the program side. Here is what I have seen separate the firms that grow inside managed programs from the ones that slowly lose share.

    1. Learn the program, not just the client

    Read the program guide. Know the submission rules, rate structure, timelines, and escalation paths. Firms that win are rarely the ones with the loudest pitch. They are the ones that make no avoidable mistakes in the process.

    2. Speed and fit beat volume

    Submitting many candidates quickly is not the goal. Submitting a few well-matched candidates quickly is. Programs measure submittal-to-hire, and a weak submittal costs you credibility with the people reviewing your work.

    3. Know your scorecard

    Most programs measure suppliers on a short list of metrics, such as time to submit, fill rate, quality of hire, and compliance. Ask what is measured, how often, and how it affects your share of requisitions. Then manage to those numbers on purpose.

    4. Keep the data clean

    Incorrect rates, late timecards, and missing paperwork cause friction that is easy to avoid. Reliable administration is a competitive advantage because so many firms treat it as an afterthought.

    5. Build the relationship behind the system

    A managed program does not remove people from the process. Program managers, account leads, and hiring managers all notice who is responsive, honest, and easy to work with. Show up for meetings and business reviews and bring ideas, not just excuses.  The program team is looking for a partner.

    6. Be honest about where you are strong

    You will not win every category. Tell the program which roles and locations you can fill well and say no to the rest. A supplier with a high fill rate on a narrow set of roles often does better than one chasing everything.

    The takeaway

    Managed programs reward reliability, clarity, and fit. The firms that treat the program as a partner, rather than an obstacle, tend to earn more over time.

    If you are a staffing firm looking to strengthen your position inside managed programs, email becky@ennisbader.com.

  • Before You Buy a VMS, Settle These Five Things

    Before You Buy a VMS, Settle These Five Things

    Photo by Imkara Visual on Unsplash

    Technology will not fix a program you have not defined yet.

    A Vendor Management System (VMS) can bring real structure to contingent labor: requisitions, approvals, rates, reporting. But software enforces the rules you give it. If the rules are unclear, the system makes the confusion faster and more expensive.

    In 30 years of implementing and managing these programs, the ones that struggle almost always skipped the same groundwork. Settle these five things before you sign anything.

    1. Governance: who decides?

    Who owns the program? Who approves exceptions? Who resolves a dispute between a hiring manager and a supplier? If the answer is “it depends,” the system will inherit that problem.

    2. Stakeholders: who needs to be in the room?

    Procurement, HR, finance, legal, IT, and the hiring managers who will use the system every day all have a stake. Programs that leave one of them out usually hear from them after launch.

    3. Data: can you trust what you have today?

    A VMS reports on the data it is given. If worker records, cost centers, and rates are inconsistent today, the first reports will be disappointing. Know your starting point and clean it up where you can before the move.

    4. Supplier strategy: who will you work with, and how?

    Decide how many suppliers you want, how they are tiered, and how you will measure them. Moving to a managed program changes the relationship with your suppliers. Tell them early and plan for it.

    5. Success metrics: how will you know it worked?

    Pick a short list of measures before launch, such as spend under management, time to fill, supplier performance, and conversion rate. If you cannot describe success in advance, you cannot judge the program or the provider afterward.

    A quick self-check

    • ☐ We can name the single owner of our contingent program.
    • ☐ Every stakeholder group has been consulted.
    • ☐ We know where our current contingent data lives and how reliable it is.
    • ☐ We have a supplier strategy, not just a supplier list.
    • ☐ We have written down what success looks like.

    If you cannot check every box, that is the work to do first. It is also where an outside perspective helps most.

    If you are evaluating an MSP, MVP, or VMS and would like a second set of eyes before you commit, message me or reach out through this site.