If your company spends between $10 and $50 million a year on contingent labor, you probably have more of a program than you realize and less control than you think.
I have spent 30 years building and running these programs. The companies that struggle most are rarely the ones with no program at all. They are the ones where the program grew by accident: a few staffing vendors added over the years, hiring managers who each negotiate their own rates, and nobody who owns the whole picture. For example, I had a customer once who thought they spent $11 million a year on contingent workers and that they had 4 suppliers that they were utilizing. What they didn’t realize was that they had 3 other vendors billing an additional $5 million annually in 1 department and the workers have all been there long enough to be converted to full time employees because no one was managing to the contracts with the suppliers.
Here is how to tell whether that describes you.
Why this spend range is different
Below about $10 million, spreadsheets and a good relationship with a couple of suppliers can carry you. Above $50 million, most companies already have a formal program because the cost of not having one is too visible.
The middle is where problems hide. The spend is large enough that small inefficiencies add up to real money. But it is small enough that no one is hired to manage it, so it falls to procurement, HR, finance or the hiring managers themselves, all of whom have other jobs.
By the numbers: vendor sprawl and visibility
A survey of 700 senior decision-makers at enterprises with more than 500 employees and over $100 million in revenue, across six countries including the US and Canada, found:
- 46% manage six or more outside vendors for their contingent workforce, and 17% manage more than 10.
- 28% named a lack of visibility into workforce data and reporting as a challenge.
Source: People2.0 research, reported by Staffing Industry Analysts, Sept. 25, 2026.
This was right in line with what I saw from the customer in my earlier example.
Here are seven warning signs that you might need a program to manage your contingent labor.
- You cannot say, quickly, how much you spend on contingent labor. If the answer takes a week and three people, you do not have visibility.
- You work with many staffing suppliers and nobody can say why. Vendor sprawl usually means each manager picked their own.
- The same role is billed at different rates. Check two departments using the same job title. Rate variation without a reason is lost margin.
- Contracts are missing, outdated or inconsistent. Terms, markups and conversion fees differ by supplier, and some workers are engaged with no agreement at all.
- Nobody owns the program. If you ask who is accountable for contingent workforce cost, quality and compliance and get several answers, the real answer is no one.
- Invoices are a recurring headache. Disputes, corrections and late approvals are rarely just an accounting issue. They point to unclear rates, weak onboarding or poor supplier communication.
- You worry about compliance but cannot prove you are covered. Worker classification, tenure limits and co-employment risk all get harder to manage without a central view.
One or two of these is normal. Four or more means you are paying for the lack of a program, even though you never chose to.
What a program actually is
When I say “program” to a company at this size, people picture a large outsourced managed service provider and a long, expensive rollout. That is one version, and it is often more than a $10-50 million company needs.
At its core, a program is just four things:
- Visibility: one view of who is working for you, through which supplier, at what rate
- Standards: consistent rates, contracts and onboarding
- Ownership: a named person accountable for results
- Measurement: a short list of metrics reviewed regularly
How you deliver those four things, with an outside provider, with technology, or mostly with your own team, is a separate decision. I cover that in the next article.
A quick self-assessment
Answer yes or no:
- We can report total contingent spend by supplier within a day.
- Our rates for the same role are consistent across departments.
- Every supplier has a current agreement with standard terms.
- One named person owns the program.
- We review supplier performance on a regular schedule.
- Hiring managers know the rules for engaging contingent workers.
Four or more “no” answers mean a program would likely pay for itself. Two or three means targeted fixes may be enough. Zero or one means you are in better shape than most.
What to do next
You do not need to make big decisions yet. The best first step is to find out where you actually stand: your total spend, your suppliers, your rates and your contracts. I will walk through that baseline in Article 3. Before that, Article 2 covers how to choose a model that fits a company your size.
If you would like help figuring out where you stand, I am happy to talk it through. Email me at becky@ennisbader.com to schedule a 20 minute discussion.

Leave a Reply